M&A Landscape:
Insurance Agencies & Brokerages
Table of Contents
Insurance Agencies & Brokerages
- Captive agencies align with a single carrier, like State Farm or Prudential.
- Independent managing agencies serve as intermediaries between carrier and client, with additional pricing, underwriting, and policy authority.
- Independent wholesale agencies play the intermediating role between other agents and the carrier, typically handling specialty or hard-to-place markets.
- Independent retail agencies serve to connect individual clients to the broader retail market, maintaining relationships with various carriers to secure optimal pricing and policies. This serves as the industry's core revenue stream.
Successful agency operation depends on excellent business judgment, proficient sales abilities, and astute interpersonal skills. Agency owners typically possess prerequisite industry training and credentials, along with significant capital and commendable credit.
The insurance industry is cyclical, driven by supply and demand dynamics. A 'hard market' signifies rising prices, whereas a 'soft market' represents falling prices. Business models favoring client acquisition and retention can significantly boost their prospects.
Additionally, business insurance pricing tends to be more unstable than personal insurance due to diverse factors. Larger firms typically have more bargaining power than individuals and can aggressively negotiate policies in line with budget constraints. Certain commercial insurance lines demonstrate greater volatility, and the competition for larger, high-commission accounts lessens volatility for smaller accounts.
On average, insurance firms operate from a lone location, employ seven individuals, and make roughly $1.2 million in yearly revenue. Effective marketing, especially referrals and online lead generation, is integral to their success. The firms are about 24% female-owned, 18% minority-owned, and 15% veteran-owned.
Approximately, 55% of insurance agencies are structured as S corporations, 22% as sole proprietorships, 16% as corporations, with the remaining operating as partnerships or non-profits. Property and casualty (P&C) firms make up 44% ($678 billion) of the total insurance marketplace including auto, home, workers' compensation, cyber, marine, and more. Life and health (L&H) insurance constitutes the remaining 56% ($877 billion) covering individual life and annuities, group life and annuities, and accident/health insurance.
US insurance agency and brokerage sales are forecast to grow at a compounded annual rate of 5.56% from 2019 to 2025, faster than the overall economy (GDP CAGR of 3.6%). This forecast from January 2021 relies on the Inforum interindustry economic model of the US economy, prepared by the Interindustry Economic Research Fund Inc.
Acquisition Drivers
This leaves a sizable middle range, primarily comprising small, family-owned, and closely held businesses. Of the 36,000 currently existing independent insurance agencies in the U.S, the majority are private, often family-owned entities. These firms will inevitably be part of the mass exit by retiring Baby Boomer owners.
Even with 700 deals occurring annually, a substantial pool of agencies remains available for transactions. Experts in the industry estimate that reported deals account for only 50% to 60% of actual transactions in a given year. Factors that make the insurance market appealing include:
- High cash flow margins & low capital intensity: Insurance agencies require minimal capital investment compared to asset-intensive industries, and their commission/fee-driven revenues produce steady dividends and scalable distributions.
- Recurring revenue stream: Insurance is often mandatory, with businesses needing liability insurance and auto insurance required by law, making it a semi-required product.
- Plentiful credit: The availability of credit has benefited PE firms, family-owned offices, and others looking to deploy capital in both equity and debt deals.
- Success breeds success: As large, PE-backed platforms began their consolidation plays, more participants were drawn to the market.
The Rise of Private Equity
In the mid-1990s, a limited number of players were pursuing mergers and acquisitions (M&A) of insurance agents and brokers on a national level. However, since 2001, the insurance industry has observed a noticeable increase in deal activity, propelled primarily by the entry of private equity firms.
Previously, annual transactions typically encompassed 200 to 300 agencies. But from around 2006 to 2007, public equity firms began showing keen interest in the insurance field. This spurred an influx of funding for consolidations and rollup transactions. By 2018, private equity was responsible for 60% of all public transactions, which spanned from first-time acquisitions to recapitalizations and PE-backed consolidations.
Recently, private equity's role in insurance agency acquisitions has slightly decreased. This primarily resulted from the Federal Reserve raising interest rates numerous times over the past year, which made borrowing more expensive for private equity, consequently cooling acquisition enthusiasm.
Despite this, the overall market remains aligned with the five-year average. Independent insurance agents seeking growth, diversification, or retirement prospects have plentiful opportunities available, in spite of private equity's diminished participation.
Given that 40% of agencies are expected to change ownership in the next five years and 17% of current agents are approaching retirement, M&A activity is predicted to bounce back strongly from Q4 onwards. Valuations hold steady, and buyer demand remains substantial, especially for appealing sellers.
High valuations bode well for sellers, and increased buyer competition creates an additional advantage: agency owners now have a multitude of choices.
In the recent past, selling agencies had limited options when choosing a perpetuation partner. These options were typically large, uniform entities offering similar resources - capital, expanded market and program access, and a defined operating structure.
Currently, agency owners consider several factors beyond just top valuation when selecting potential perpetuation partners. It is beneficial for sellers to keep in mind their specific objectives when reviewing offers. Local agencies, once eclipsed by financially powerful PE firms, are now active participants, with many owners now able to prospect agencies that were considered inaccessible in the past.
M&A Statistics: Q1-Q3 2023
In recent years, the independent agency system has undergone significant consolidation. Mergers and acquisitions have become a new normal, presenting unique opportunities and challenges for independent insurance agents seeking growth, diversification, or retirement.
Despite a slight decline in deal volume due to increased interest rates, the M&A domain in the property/casualty insurance sector in the US and Canada remains vibrant. When compared to the historic average rates, Q3 2023's 168 transactions, a 34% decrease, suggests normalization after a previous boom largely driven by private equity-backed buyers.
Over the past year, the Fed raised interest rates a total of nine times. This move nudged asset values, including insurance agencies and tech stocks, downwards. The upshot- expensive borrowing costs for private equity players, which led to a cooling off in the acquisitions game.
The H1 2023 count (359 deals) is down 24% from 2022 but still hangs tight with the previous 5-year average. With a 34% drop in transactions in Q3 2023, the market appears to be normalizing after the recent frenzy fueled by private equity buyers.
- Q1: 17% decrease from Q1 2022 with a total of 158 transactions.
- Q2: 36% decrease from Q2 2022 with a total of 177 transactions.
- Q3: 34% decrease from Q3 2022 with a total of 172 transactions.
Year-over-Year Overview
2022 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2021 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2020 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2019 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2018 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2017 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2016 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2015 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2014 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
2013 Deal Activity
The 2022 M&A market cooled off amidst rising interest rates and economic instabilities, leading to a cautious buyer stance. There were 987 deals, marking an 8% decrease from 2021, and a sharper 17% fall in certain categories. Despite the slowdown, deal activity still exceeded the 5-year average. The leading buyer was Acrisure with 107 deals.
M&A Seller Trends
2018 Seller Trends
Property and casualty (P&C) agencies constituted half of the total transactions in 2018 (50%), a slight decrease from 56% in 2017. Other sellers included employee benefits agencies (22%), multiline agencies (18%), and others (10%).
The majority of these deals, 82.4%, were represented by retail agencies, with the remaining 17.6% made up of wholesale agencies, managing general agencies, and specialty firms.
2017 Seller Trends
P&C agencies once again topped the sales in 2017 with 301 transactions. Employee benefits (EB) firms reported a significant sales increase, from 93 in 2016 to 174 in 2017, largely driven by Alera and Acrisure.
2016 Seller Trends
P&C agencies dominated the market in 2016, accounting for 53% of all transactions. The prominence of these firms had gradually grown from representing only a quarter of all acquisitions eight years prior to surpassing the 50% mark by 2015
2015 Seller Trends
2015 saw a preference for P&C agencies in the M&A market, with these firms representing 57% of all transactions. This trend likely reflected the fallout from the 2008 financial downturn.
Key influences included: Increased deal activity, Retirement of baby boomer agency owners, Initial anxiety over the impact of the Affordable Care Act on the Employee Benefits sector, Buyers' familiarity with the operations of the P&C sector.
2014 Seller Trends
In 2014, Property/Casualty (P&C) agencies were the main contributors to M&A market growth. All seller groups, notably P&C agencies, Employee Benefits (EB), P&C/EB combined, and others, experienced a common trend: a peak in transactions in 2012, followed by a decrease in 2013, and recovery in 2014.
M&A Buyer Trends
2022 Buyer Trends
The 2022 M&A market registered a 5% rise in activity from private buyers, while PE/Hybrid buyers noted a slight decrease in transactions from 77% in 2021 to 74% in 2022. Seven of the top ten buyers had fewer deals compared to 2021. Top-performing buyers for the year included Acrisure (107 deals), PCF Insurance (71 deals), and Hub (70 deals).
2021 Buyer Trends
In 2021, Private Equity-supported and hybrid buyer transactions comprised 76% of all deals. Acrisure, PCF Insurance, and Hub emerged as top-performing buyers with 122, 99, and 61 deals, respectively. Large privately-owned firms (e.g., IMA and Heffernan) showed a greater likelihood towards acquisitions. Top-performing buyers for the year included Acrisure (122 deals), PCF Insurance (99 deals) and Hub (61 deals).
2020 Buyer Trends
PE/Hybrid maintained a significant presence in 2020 M&A activities, making up 71% of all transactions. Top-performing buyers were Acrisure (108 deals) maintaining their four-year average of 100 deals annually, Hub (64 deals), and BroadstreetPartners (58 deals).
2019 Buyer Trends
The PE/Hybrid group ushered in 69% of transactions in 2019. Acrisure, with 98 transactions, emerged as the top buyer, followed by Hub (51 deals), and AssuredPartners (44 deals). Concentration among the most active buyers experienced a slight decline in 2019. It accounted for 58% of the total, falling from the previous year's 61%. Five out of the ten most active buyers completed fewer deals in 2019 than they did in 2018.
2018 Buyer Trends
PE/Hybrid brokers led the 2018 M&A activities, executing over two-thirds of all transactions. Acrisure emerged as the top buyer with 101 transactions, followed by Hub (59 deals), and AssuredPartners (37 deals). The concentration of M&A activity among the most active buyers continued to increase.
2017 Seller Trends
In 2017, the top ten buyers accounted for 56% of all transactions. Acrisure was particularly notable with 92 deals, followed by Hub (49 deals), and Alera (38 deals). Assured Partners, NFP, and Seeman Holtz also closed more than 20 transactions each. The number of unique buyers increased to 173 in 2017 from 153 in 2016, including 126 single-transaction buyers.
2016 Buyer Trends
Private equity-backed firms led in transactions in 2016, accounting for over half of the total transactions. Acrisure led with 50% more transactions than the next player. OneDigital acquired seven times the number of assets it did in the same period in 2015. Of note is the surge in transaction correlation among the top 15 buyers; this group accounted for 60% of total transactions in 2016, showing a rising trend from 54% in 2015 and 51% in 2014.
2015 Buyer Trends
Private equity-backed firms emerged as key players by 2015, accounting for approximately 54% of all transactions. This growth can be attributed to an abundance of private equity capital and limited profitable investments available. In such an environment, the insurance brokerage business became an attractive prospect for investors.
When comparing the average transactions completed by different buyer types in 2008 and 2015, PE-backed buyers stood out as the most active and led the top-10 list of most active buyers and individual buyers over four years.
2014 Buyer Trends
Despite the increase in M&A deals closed by PE-backed brokers, the number of firms closing deals remained steady, signifying that each firm is closing more transactions on average. In 2014, 19 PE-backed firms announced 158 transactions, translating into over eight deals per firm, an increase from fewer than four in 2008.
In 2014, 44% of transactions were conducted by private equity-backed firms, a substantial increase from 34% in 2012. Private buyers reported 113 transactions in 2014, the highest ever, while public brokers saw increased activity after a quiet 2013. Since 2011, the top 20 buyers gradually increased their share of total transactions, closing 63% of all deals in 2014, compared to 52% in 2008. Top buyers were increasingly more active, not necessarily that there were more buyers in the market.
2013 Buyer Trends
In 2013, PE-backed buyers led transactions across all categories. The total number of PE-backed firm buyers had climbed consistently. In 2008, 15 PE firms closed 49 deals, averaging 3.27 deals each. By 2013 this average increased to nearly double, with 16 different PE firms closing an average of 5.88 deals each.
Buy, sell, and value
with Cake.
Cake connects independent insurance agents looking to sell a book of business or a slice – a chosen group of accounts – with other agents looking to grow their business. Now you can buy, sell, and get a valuation for your book, all with Cake.